SELENE has now a nickname : KAGUYA.
http://www.jaxa.jp/topics/2007/06_e.html
Edit :
And Emily searched for the origin of the name
http://www.planetary.org/blog/article/00000996/
http://www.planetary.org/news/2007/0618_Kaguya_Approaches_Launch.html
By Yasunori Matogawa
June 18, 2007
How are they going to insert this into polar orbit? Given the mass of the hardware and to capabilities of the rocket I don't see how they are going to achieve this.
The Moon's gravity can be used to effect the plane change for entering a polar orbit around the Moon.
Seems like the new launch date is September 13. So not a big delay for Kaguya. (But already very hostile press )
Is there a source somewhere on the Internet for that date? (Even if it's in Japanese?)
--Emily
sorry I forgot:
for the September 13 date:
http://msdb.honeywell-tsi.com/launches.asp
also JAXA released a small report which says they pushed the launch to September since they need around one month of repair.: http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/07/20070725_sac_kaguya.pdf
So this not such a big delay.
http://msdb.honeywell-tsi.com/missioninfo.asp?Mission=SELENE/Kaguya
The nice thing about lunar missions is that if you miss a launch window, you only have to wait a month for the next one to come along.
Lots of photos of Kaguya being prepped for launch:
http://jda.jaxa.jp/jda/p3_e.php?time=N&mode=level&genre=4&category=4064&mission=4067
(Want to blog these but Cassini has to stop sending so many great photos from Iapetus first!)
--Emily
It will be delayed by a day due to bad weather, new launch date from Tanegashima is Sep. 14 Friday
A little more than 5 hours before launch... Godspeed, Kaguya!
Rock the Moon and roll to Mars
This message may be flying today
I don't suppose anyone knows of a live link for the launch...? Don't know if JAXA customarily does this or not.
http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/live/index_e.html
It's there somewheres....
Sorry
This is it:
http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/live/weblive_e.html
No word if Lipovitan will sponsor coverage.
...thanks, Ly, and wouldn't you know it: I just found it & was coming back to post that same link! (I gotta be less lazy...)
Coverage should start approx. 45 minutes from now (currently 2349 GMT 13 Sept).
EDIT: Kaguya coverage is live now http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/live/weblive_e.html! Can't understand a syllable except for "hai", but GO KAGUYA!!!!!
First time I've missed the ex in awhile...she could've translated!
EDIT2: Wow...they just showed a shot of what appeared to be a crowd of people in a shopping mall or something watching the coverage on a big TV...seems as if there's a lot of domestic public interest, which is always great to see!
EDIT3: She's up!!! SWEET launch so far...most beautiful launch site ever on a wave-breaking beach, and the high temp (29 deg C) plus undoubtedly high humidity produced this amazing shockwave donut of condensation around the payload fairing that stretched & transformed into a cylinder during max Q...really remarkable, never seen the like before. That H-2 has some serious juice! External cam showed the horizon of the Earth briefly, then cut to commentators...so far, running sweet & true.
It's up! I blogged what I could from the English translation.. Now I have to go put the baby to bed. If anybody sees anything new on the status can you please please post it here?
--Emily
10:20 PM EDT: Payload separation!
Airbag
...and that's it for the commentary. Nothing new on the launch site home page yet. Cherilynn has promised me updates and pictures from Tokyo, though, so hopefully tonight or tomorrow I'll have more...
--Emily
Got to love that low-tech approach to illustrating the launch vehicle's progress on the broadcast - a hand held clipboard with stickers for each phase (e.g. 1st stage separation) that were peeled away one by one!
Airbag
That was pretty funny. It was a bit Python-esque -- for reasons I can't quite explain, it reminded me of the http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLAamUlu-H8.
And when they were outside, with the hardhats, it reminded me of Japanese game shows -- I kept expecting one of the men to suddenly have to go through some "challenge."
There's something about Japan that gets utterly lost upon translation to English. Beyond foreign, it's alien. I know there are some Japanese readers of this forum -- I would love to know from one of them if Americans appear inexplicable and alien to you. And -- are Europeans less so? Or more so?
--Emily
Anybody know what the little orange bobbing head guy on the bottom left was? Jaxa Mascot? Generic Cute Japanese Icon?
When are these two orbits going to be completed and when the lunar injection burn is going to occur?
Is there a replay of that spectacular launch somewhere?
Yes, it's available on nasaspaceflight.com
Hi!
This is the video of the JAXA program for the Selene launch:
http://www.sondasespaciales.com/public/archivos/Lanzamiento%20Selene%20-%20140907%20-%20Jai.asf
(311 MB - ASF)
The flag: 0h5m30sec
Launch with a looooooong countdown: 0h47m (poor quality)
Launch Replay: 1h36m (good quality)
Hai-counter now in: 3827
Will Kaguya arrive at Moon within 3 days? Haven't found the Kaguya's mission timing.
from http://spaceflightnow.com/h2a/selene/070914launch.html article
Thanks Nop for good detail.
I see that Kaguya will travel slower to Moon than Apollo. This is for the cheapest travel to Moon without has to much acceleration and breaking. Anyway, the time will fly fast.
thanks nop and subaru for the inside scoop -
and godspeed, princess!
HIGH GAIN ANTENNA DEPLOYMENT (In-flight image taken of HGA!)
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/09/20070915_kaguya_e.html
SOLAR PANEL DEPLOYMENT (In-flight image taken of "Paddle"!)
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/09/20070915_kaguya-2_e.html
I expect the images (and HDTV movies) of such scenes to be even more spectacular than what was possible in the late 1960s. Of course, this all depends on how compressed, well exposed etc. the imagery will be. I'm looking forward to that.
Any news on the first manuevre?
Where is Kaguya? "It is in the position of present KAGUYA."
http://www.selene.jaxa.jp/en/communication/position_e.htm
Makes you appreciate JPL's Solar System Simulator a lot more.
nop, do you know if Kaguya will acquire approach imagery as it nears the Moon? Would be interesting to see how image products will looks from this spacecraft with science target, not hardware (though those images are pretty cool, don't get me wrong).
Do we have any information about end of mission scenarios? At least the main spacecraft, and eventually the subsatellites, should impact as the orbits evolve and are not maintained. The subsatellites are probably not controllable to target an impact as SMART-1 was targeted, but the main spacecraft could be controlled.
I only live for points on a map.
Phil
We are now about 5 days away from LOI for Kaguya. I want to note
that we are in the last few days of an historic period - a time when
there are no active man-made devices operating on, or near, the Moon.
Once Kaguya enters lunar orbit, I believe that we will be starting an era
when there will ALWAYS be a functioning representative of mankind at
the Moon, either manned or unmanned. We are about to enter a new epoch,
one in which mankind has a permanent presence at the Moon. Unless something
drastic occurs, I foresee no gaps in this lunar presence for the next several
centuries, perhaps for the next several millenia.
It all starts in a few days.
Another Phil
...terrific sentiment. I hope it's true.
Would like to know about how fast will Kaguya be approaching to the Moon at the LOI point. How long will the engines be firing during the orbit injection?
http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/index_e.html
Orbit adjustment on the second orbit.
Phil
Pronouncing it
I was at the IAC conference in Hyderabad, India last week. They had good presentations on Kaguya, and I'm really looking forward to it.
I learned that I was pronouncing it wrong. We were told by a JAXA person that it is pronounced KA-gu-ya, not ka-GU-ya.
Apparently, ka-GU-ya means 'furniture store.'
There's a funny joke in there somewhere.
Quote:
"Apparently, ka-GU-ya means 'furniture store.'
There's a funny joke in there somewhere."
Because it will be a treat for all us arm-chair space scientists?..........
or
Sofa so good for Japanese Lunar probe?
Hmmm, nope your wrong, there is not a funny joke in there somewhere
Brian
Kaguya is carrying a high-definition TV camera as her big furniture and now she have sent a nice picture to us.
KAGUYA (SELENE) Successful Image Taking by the High Definition Television (HDTV)
http://www.jaxa.jp/topics/2007/10_e.html
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/20071001_kaguya_j.html (in Japanese)
Delta-Vp2 was successful and now Kaguya is on the Moon transfer orbit.
The picture was taken on September 29, 110,000 km away from the Earth - the most distant HDTV image ever
You can see the South America.
The larger image is here. Enjoy!
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/img/20071001_kaguya.jpg
Thanks for the heads up on that - great stuff!
Doug
Wow! That looks so promising!
Is that a colorized image or an actual color one? Looks like color, but South America is too invariably blue?
It's early spring in South America. There's a lot of moisture in the air over the entire continent. That, combined with the rather extreme slant angle through which we're looking at the ground in this image (putting a lot of air between the viewpoint and the ground) means that yes, it likely is a true-color view.
-the other Doug
I have no idea about the specs, but maybe the color filters are not ideal for "real" color pictures and are maximised to bring out color differences on the moon? Anyone know?
Awesome photo, nop... Can't wait to see HDTV images and actual video footage of the Moon when Kaguya begins official science operations. Obviously.
After taking a look at the channels, it is probably true this is a RGB image, but the green and especially the blue channel were overexposed, leading to the unnaturally (?) blue appearance. Here's an attempt at producing a more typical Earth appearance:
According to JAXA report is that Kaguya is now heading toward the Moon. The LOI would be this Thursday October 4. Important day. Later, the relay satellite will be separated on Oct 9, VRAD by Oct 12 and finally Kaguya will be in Lunar Orbit by October 19.
I presume they mean October 4, Japan Time (as in the LOI is still on October 3, 2:01 pm Pacific Daylight Time)?
BTW, they updated the "Position of KAGUYA" page:
http://www.selene.jaxa.jp/en/communication/position_e.htm
Nice little image there. JPL needs to have that kind of animation instead of the Solar System Simulator.
Kaguya has a monitoring camera for cheking the solar array paddle deployment. This camera happened to capture another Earth image.
You can see the Earth through a small clearance between the body and the paddle.
http://www.selene.jaxa.jp/ja/communication/com_information_j.htm (Sorry, in Japanese)
http://www.selene.jaxa.jp/image/communication/thumnail/img_071002_01_s.jpg
And now the movie has been released.
http://jda.jaxa.jp/jda/v4_e.php?v_id=0496f90d5e5acc06af3087a364c940c8&mode=level&time=N&genre=4&category=4064
The change of the image is extremely slight and slow. Be patient
Earth's rotation dictates features should be appearing, not disappearing at the western terminator.
The QT version doesn't work for me and it's the only one that would allow scrolling back and forth in the movie, without rebuffering. From what I can see in the WMV, most of the "moving" is KAGUYA moving farther from Earth with only a hint of rotation. The pointing is remarkably steady, though. I almost wish there was that "Apollo-like" human hand factor to show it's actual footage, not CGI renderings.
Yeah, QT doesn't work for me either. I wish they had posted these in some downloadable format that I could play with
That pic of the solar paddle that happened to catch Earth in it is pretty neat! nop, could you perhaps help out with translation of that page? Here is what the Google translator produces, which isn't bad; only the last sentence is unintelligible:
Cool cool cool, nop!!! Been much more impressed with Kaguya so far than with many other missions...sweet bird, great outreach!
Kaguya should be in lunar orbit about 13 hours after this posting...
Whaddayaknow... it IS round.
Thank you very much for your posts and translations, nop! You are really a great help in spreading news from Japan!
--Emily
"At 5:55 a.m. on Thursday, a small engine was fired to change the probe's direction and speed and send it into an elliptical orbit around the moon's north and south poles. JAXA officials said the firing of the engine went well."
http://mdn.mainichi.jp/national/news/20071004p2a00m0na036000c.html
Phil
At the beginning, JAXA says that Kaguya is mainly as an experimental spacecraft to prove new technologies.. Thus, I presume that this is one of the low-profile public relations' reasons since this kind of mission has high risk of success. Hope, that all new technologies would run fine after many past setback lessons.
looks like they were successful..see http://spaceflightnow.com/h2a/selene/071004loi.html article
edit:lets hope http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/index_e.html has an official update soon!!
press release is http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/20071005_kaguya_e.html.
I am pleased to share the success of LOI with you all
I wonder when the first images will be published
A new update from Kaguya. It has already performed the 3rd LOI.
The First LOI:
Injected orbit
Apogee altitude 11,741 km
Perigee altitude 101 km
Period 16 hours 42 minutes
The second LOI:
Apogee altitude 5,694 km
Perigee altitude 108 km
Period 7 hours 53 minutes
The third LOI: has already conducted. There are still three more.
More details http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/index_e.html
Just a curiosity, how does the spacecraft able to lower the Apogee?
Trying to understand it, it is done by firing the rocket when the spacecraft is reaching the apogee so that the next loop will go slower and thus reducing its next apogee altitude and continues until reaching the desired altitude?
The Relay satellite "Rstar" will be released tomorrow.
Phil
Rstar was successfully separated.
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/20071009_kaguya_e.html
Nice update and a couple of spacecraft moonshots:
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/20071009_kaguya_e.html#at01
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/img/20071009_kaguya_05l.jpg
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/img/20071009_kaguya_07l.jpg
Enjoy........
Brian
All credit to JAXA - you guys know how to make this cool...
cover it in cameras
Doug
FYI, I hope this mapping image will help you figure out where Kaguya is
Mapping by Prof. Naru Hirata (Aizu Univ.) and article by Shin-ya Matsuura.
http://smatsu.air-nifty.com/lbyd/2007/10/post_38e8.html (Click the image to enlarge)
Many congratulations to JAXA after the disappointments about Nozomi et al. This mission is shaping up really nicely and there is a lot to look forward to. Those images of the moon with parts of the spacecrfat in the foreground remind me of Rosetta's fly-by of Mars.... as if we the viewers are looking out from a spacercraft which we are on-board.
http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/index_e.html
VRAD (Vstar) separation coming up...
http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/topics/pdf/1012_0830_vstar_e.pdf
Phil
.... and the VRAD satellite has departed, now-named "OUNA" meaning an "honorable elderly woman." How nice. A couple of photos show it sliding away into the black...
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/20071012_kaguya_e.html
Kenny
Getting there...
http://www.jaxa.jp/countdown/f13/topics/pdf/1019_0925_loi56_e.pdf
Now for the images...
Phil
Here's the latest - images from the monitoring camera in low orbit.
Phil
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/20071021_kaguya.pdf
You can see more images captured by the monitoring camera at:
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/20071021_kaguya.pdf
Sorry, it's written mainly in Japanese...
Thanks for the links to those pics nop.
Is anyone else sitting there grinning, thinking "Those are just cool!!" ?
They are indeed cool.
In http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/10/img/20071021_kaguya_02.jpg, that would not be Earth in the background instead of part of the spacecraft, would it?
I spotted that too... very nice...!
Only problem with these images is that Moon-watchers like me are going to spend hours trying to identify craters on them... !!!
I'm looking out for the crater "Eddington" so I can plug both the probe's mission and my astro society in the local press! Very useful for publicity and recruitment!
I took all 13 images and tweaked the color balance in them as it appears the blue channel overwhelms everything. A similar case was present with the HDTV image of Earth earlier. Hopefully they'll fix this during normal operations.
This tweak inevitably brought some overexposure in areas where the blue channel was already saturated.
I made an http://www.fileden.com/files/2007/9/14/1431389/kaguya.gif of all the frames (2 megabytes).
Here are a couple of sample shots:
nop - screen captures would be really useful, thanks, simply because I'm heading out to work now and don't have time to go exploring that .pdf file!
ugordan - brilliant idea changing the colour balance, thanks, and the animation is great too.
How spoiled are we with all this talent here, seriously?!!
Beautiful work, Dilo! God, it seems as if we could just reach out and touch it...
nprev, I think you've put your finger on why these kinds of photos -- with bits of spacecraft parts obtruding into them -- are so cool. If the spacecraft gets its thumb in the way of the lens, then why not me?
--Emily
Having parts of the spacecraft framing these vistas provide us psychological referents. It vastly increases the ability to imagine yourself actually *in* the place you're looking at.
I think it says something about the human desire/need to explore that these images, which include spacecraft "framing" views, are somehow more satisfying than any others.
-the other Doug
Agreed. Those Kagyusha "port-hole" views remind me of Rosetta flying past Mars...
http://www.esa.int/images/CIVA_Mars_30_H.jpg
KAGUYA rules....
Yeah.... the porthole effect.... the virtual thumb cover the Earth ....
All.... I remember watching Ranger 7 impact the Moon... and Apollo 8 give us Earthrise on a Christmas Eve in 1968.... seeing these new images now still gives me chills......
We are returning.
TEARS!!!
Craig
More pictures - the various instruments are being deployed.
Phil
http://www.jaxa.jp/topics/2007/img/topics_20071031_e.pdf
here!
http://www.jaxa.jp/topics/2007/11_e.html
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/11/20071107_kaguya_movie_e.html
That is just so very very cool. They should give 1080i MOV's to Apple to put on their trailers website
Doug
Happy...I am a happy man...
Truly incredible... just like being there!
The best orbital views since Apollo... and if the full file is proper HDTV at a reasoable frame rate, then this is better quality than Apollo...
Anyone care to post a full-res screenshot? I'm at work and can't play the file.
Thanks, Ustrax!
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/11/20071107_kaguya_e.html
There are links to full res. image on thumbnailes.
No it is time for me to say...thanks foe!
Sweet stuff! I thought we'd have to wait until humans get back there for shots like these. All we need is an Earthrise sequence now.
If you link to the http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/11/20071107_kaguya.swf directly, you get the whole scene and player in bigger-o-vision.
Andy
Who had thought we would get some High Definition TeleVision from the Moon?
Well it had to come from the Japanese anyway
A new HDTV movie of eath-rise and earth-set has been released:
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/11/20071113_kaguya_e.html
It reminds me of the great Christmas earth-rise take by Apollo 8
FYI, someone uploaded the capture of NHK news program featuring the previous HDTV moon image:
(the reso is higher than the flash video by JAXA. Strictly speaking, please note that the copyright is violated )
http://stage6.divx.com/user/tanabota/video/1833421/Kaguya(SELENE)
And another good news is that Kaguya successfully observed the gravity field of the far side of the moon directly by four-way Doppler observation using RSAT.
(the release only in Japanese. It's just notification of success, and no data have been reeased yet)
http://www.isas.jaxa.jp/j/topics/topics/2007/1112.shtml
My jaw refuses to leave the floor...
Amazing stuff!
The Apollo 8 comparison is apt, nop. Far different view, though, than any obtained by Apollo (an upside down & nearly-full Earth!) Dramatic; inspiring!
Fab images! And for orientation, the foreground ridge is the misnamed "peak of eternal light' between Shackleton (the real south polar crater, just above the copyright symbol) and de Gerlache, at the left edge. Malapert Mountain is just under the Earth. This is the best image I've ever seen for illustrating the geography of the place, which is also intended to be the target for the Chandrayaan-1 impact probe and the Selene 2 lander/rover.
Phil
That Flash-player is a little balky, but the images are more than enough to totally make my morning.
Wow!
That movie won't play on our system (previous ones did). How big is the file?
I'd really like to show my students . . .
Sadly, I can't get the JAXA server to show me the movie -- they must be getting hit hard. The best I can manage right now is this animation (click to enlarge):
http://www.planetary.org/image/20071113_kaguya_03l_anim.gif
--Emily
Someone put it on Youtube:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkHuRRDshhg
Obviously the quality takes a hit, but at least we can actually watch it.
All..
I can access the original site now. Had trouble earlier.
Almost like being there...... awesomely beautiful..... thanks JAXA.
Tears..
Craig
Emily,
Thank you
Thank you
Thank you
Thank you
THANK YOU!!!!!!!
unbeeeleeeevable.
And yet, on that Stage6 page nop linked to, there is something to make the blood pressure rise...
There is only one comment left so far on the clip. "nice cg"
Makes ya wanna spit...!
-the other Doug
Don't let it bug you too much. I realised a long time ago that such beauty is not meant to be appreciated by people like that.
Couldn't agree more. In fact, I sent one of the images to a friend of mine and made sure to mention that "this is not fake!"
Truly remarkable.
Just amazing, the best quality moving images ever returned from the Moon. Nicely composed, beautifully exposed, a camera with esthetic rather than exclusively 'dry science' guiding it! The value of obtaining imagery like this for it's own sake is a rare thing in US mission planning, Carolyn Porco had a struggle obtaining more than the 'bare science' images of the backlit rings mosaic, for what turned out to be the most widely circulated image of the Cassini mission. Let this be a lesson for what kind of imagery is worth obtaining. How long will it be until the US has a high def camera in Lunar or even Martian orbit?
One can imagine rotating the spacecraft so the camera turns around and back to its direction of travel over a few minutes mantaining the pictorial composition as much as possible. This would give interesting perspective effects as the foreground topography sped by faster in relation to the background from all angles. I would also suggest Orienting the camera straight down for passes over the western Orientale basin when it is suitably lit which could reveal the still poorly known topography there.
Don Davis
There often seems overload in the JAXA server now because of too much access.
If you have any trouble in seeing flash videos, try the mirror posted by an anonymous advocate
http://space.geocities.jp/jaxa_kaguya/kaguya_480-270earth.flv
I've read an informal episode that the onboard HDTV plan caused some controversy in scientists at first, because the HDTV camera is very fragile and its effectiveness is uncertain than other scientific equipment candidates. But Prof. Matogawa insisted on the importance of science outreach toward the public, and made much effort for the plan. Now I'm realizing that he was right
Yes, he was...and glad to see that JAXA's learning the lesson early! This outreach should be a real boon for Japan's future UMSF efforts.
Wonderful movie specially by observing the Earth-rise and Earth-set!
This movie has two Earthset and they are different. Hence, I am guessing that the first ones is that Kaguya was flying over the North pole and the last ones corresponds to South pole. Am I right?
P.D. After visiting the Macplinger's post about JAXA's link and it has already answered to my questions.
New images from the science cameras:
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/11/20071116_kaguya_e.html
Very promising!
Phil
At 10m/pixel, the Smart-1 impact crater should be too small but at least the ejecta might be visible
A resolution of 10 m/pixel is also not sufficient to identify Apollo remains, but we should be able to discern ground disturbance at the landing sites.
New videos taken by the HD camera:
(resolution is low )
http://jda.jaxa.jp/jda/v3_j.php?mode=search&genre=-1&keyword=%A4%AB%A4%B0%A4%E4&submit=%B8%A1%BA%F7%B3%AB%BB%CF
Some HDTV (1280x720) footage has surfaced up on the web, complete with Japanese titles.
A hundred seconds in length, it can be found here: http://video-veuillezpas.stage6.com/1833421.divx (261 megabytes!)
They overdid it a bit with the sharpening filter for my taste, but still it's pretty spectacular. Too bad they're not the recent Earth-involving shots at normal speed, but the 8x speed-ups.
Wow, nice http://jda.jaxa.jp/jda/v4_j.php?v_id=f3745192d932c38111e2f5495a67d6c9&mode=search&keyword=%A4%AB%A4%B0%A4%E4 You may think ol' Luna is boring compared with Iapetus or other moons, but it still has plenty of beauty for my taste.
EDIT: I don't think we will be debating white-on-black or black-on-white in this example.
...absolutely stunning! The contrast between Tsiolkovsky & the surrounding terrain is really remarkable.
I hope they'll lower the orbit down to 10 kms for the last extension!
It already give me the feeling to be there anyway.
I'm looking forward to JAXA's first Mars orbiter with HDTV... (Yes, I know, bandwidth restrictions & all...)
LRO brackets the Kaguya resolution: global stereo and multispectral at 100 m/pixel, high resolution at 1 m/pixel (approx. values).
Somewhere I have seen a table comparing the current set of cameras. I'll try to find it and post it.
Phil
It's probably not really difficult to maintain a 10 or 15 km lunar orbit. You need 2 things.. maybe 3.
1.) A GOOD gravity model, reasonably high resolution, including the farside. You need to predict the exact spacecraft trajectory several orbits in advance to 1 km or better accuracy.
2.) Good tracking to verify what's the real orbit as opposed to the predict. A real-time engineering-ops lidar or RF altimiter wouldn't hurt.
3.) A propulsion system, maybe ion, maybe hypergolics running low thrust engines
You simply need to design a vehicle that will do an orbit trim maneuver or two every orbit. Just a 1/2 km tweek... just keep it circular within a small amount.
I can see a sustained 25km lunar orbit, maybe, but I think a 10km orbit would be pushing it. A lot. After all, the Moon is lumpy, and not just gravitationally -- there are some mountains (well, basin and crater rims, mostly) that rise nearly 10km up from their surrounding terrains.
And, as the gallows humor that surrounded the Apollo 8 flight had it, "60 miles? Just wait 'til you get a load of that 61-mile-high mountain on the Far Side...!"
-the other Doug
No problem at all Mps, welcome to UMSF!
Wow...a stable 86 deg low orbit sounds like a real opportunity for an ultra-high resolution global mapping mission, or perhaps escaping volatile sensing/monitoring...
I'm not so sure about the 'frozen orbits'. I could be wrong - I seem to remember being wrong once... - but here, I think this is probably talking about the orbit plane being fixed with respect to the sun, so you have the same surface illumination all the time. Certain inclinations and orbit shapes give just the right combination of gravitational effects that the orbit is always, let's say, 15 degrees from the terminator.
Low lunar orbits are unstable because of the 'lumpy' gravitational field caused by mascons, which in typical low orbits cause the perilune to migrate up and down over time in complex ways - if I understand it correctly, right now, Kaguya's perilune is ascending, but later it will descend until it has to be corrected. The effects of the Earth, the sun and mascons together make life complicated. I don't think this can be 'frozen'.
Phil
I'd think mascons* are by far the greatest destabilizing factor for such a low orbit (10 km), with Earth and Sun getting progressively more important (and mascons less important) at higher orbits.
* mascons and high mountain peaks, that is.
We've got two more cratering experiments due before Kaguya, Chang'e 1, LRO and Chandaraan 1 will be anywhere near end of life. I'm hoping that they go for barn-storming low-altitude science instead of crashing them into polar crater
Regarding frozen orbits, I couldn't find the original paper, but here's an http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2006/06nov_loworbit.htm that is derived from it.
Here is some info about the problem which delayed Kaguyas launch.
http://www.yomiuri.co.jp/dy/features/science/20071120TDY03104.htm
Some unfortunate news: due to copyright issues, JAXA will not distribute on the Web the full resolution HD movies taken by Kaguya .
See their FAQ (if you manage to understand the poor Japanese-to-English translation).
http://www.selene.jaxa.jp/en/communication/com_faq_e.htm
That is unfortunate and quite a loss to the PR effect in the rest of the world, IMHO. Giving a broadcasting corporation copyright for the hires footage seems weird. Did they sponsor or make the HDTV camera?
That is unfortunate indeed. I hope there are strong responses both here and elsewhere that lead to a change of thinking.
Without knowing the underlying reasons for this decision, I don't think we should be judging it. After all, we're lucky we even saw TV footage from the moon, all of that could be regarded as a gesture of good will on the mission's behalf. Personally, though, I wasn't pleased when I found out the HDTV exclusive would go to Discovery Channel. Why have "exclusives" in the first place? Why not just show the entire world? Could the entire camera be on a profit-based reasoning, selling HDTV footage at a nice price?
I have a DIVX of one of them already. It's neive to imagine they won't get online quickly. The grim reality of it is this - if JAXA don't release it via the web on their own terms, in top notch quality - then it will end up being distributed as dodgy quality DIV-X's without people being particularly aware of where it's come from and how. They've missed a trick there. We've had some cool stills, and some cool low res movies - perhaps lots of Yen are involved in some way - but it's a fairly short sighted way of doing things.
Doug
I'm surprised. I would have expected most here to be in favor of
the commercialization/popularization of space exploration. I don't
think you can have one without the other. If sponsorship of an
HDTV helps pay for a mission that also happens to perform useful
science, what's wrong with that?
Well - to assume this is a commercialisation issue is to make assumptions about the camera, its funding, its contribution to the spacecraft as a whole and what the reasoning behind the decision is.
If a corporation funds an instrument, but releases half a dozen stills and a 1/5th res movie....then you have to wonder what the point is in sending the full res camera in the first place? Clearly in this instance, commercialisation and popularisation are at odds with one another.
Doug
I'm gonna take a WAG & speculate that NHK purchased exclusive distro rights for the HDTV products as a condition of its support so that it can construct some sort of product for its own marketing: TV special, IMAX-style movie, something like that. So, we'll see it all, but probably not till well after the iron has grown cold...
I don't know why a commercial enterprise would have exclusive rights,
but I expect that there is an advantage to JAXA. And what's good for
JAXA is good for space exploration, right? The benefit may be tiny, but
all journeys begin with one step. If ten years from now, JAXA launches
the first wholly sponsored lunar rover, who will complain?
As to quality of released video, I would hope that Discovery Channel will
make make good use of high quality images for some great programming
that will reach the masses. Perhaps there could be pay per view available
on the Discovery Channel web site. Or even free, with adverts paying.
I for one find this exciting if indeed it is a first step to greater corporate
sponsorship of space exploration.
One thing I wonder - is the broadcasting company going to try to keep them off the web indefinitely, or are they holding them back long enough so that they can show the best footage first. Not knowing anything about Japanese television, it is hard to tell.
Even if not well executed (in some opinions) at least it's something to build on.
I can only hope that whatever Discovery Channel uses the video for is very successful
and results in increased sponsorship in the future.
This may be similar to the music download situation where for a time music enthusiasts
were spoiled with a treasure of free music online and revolted when asked to pay.
A balance has to be found between free and paid material if sponsorship is to be involved.
The space enthusiasts may be upset by production delays, but in the end the
mission's appeal to the masses will be enhanced by the finished product, not
diminished. (Of course, I'm making assumptions about the product.) I do think
high quality images should be available on line in a controlled manner. These
are the things that need to be worked out as sponsorship of space exploration
grows (hopefully).
I'm betting on NHK doing a BBC- or Discovery-style documentary...so they'll run the camera for quite some time to acquire enough footage, with an emphasis on "wow" shots. Don't expect anything for a year or so.
Yes, but... can you imagine the following scenario?
ARMSTRONG: OK, I'm gonna step off the LM, now. That's one...
CRONKITE: Thanks for watching. A full video of the rest of this Moonwalk will be available for purchase sometime in November. Please tune in to the CBS Evening News for another twenty seconds of this amazing scene. Until then, I'm Walter Cronkite, looking forward to a huge bonus in my paycheck. Good night.
-the other Doug
Capitalism is what makes the world go 'round, right?
Our local baseball and hockey teams used to play in the Thunderdome and
Ice Palace (great names!) respectively. Now, due to corporate sponsorship,
it's Tropicana Field and the St. Petersburg Times Forum.
On the bright side, it should make for fewer public mission-naming contests,
the results of which I've seen criticized here.
If this were a solely privately funded launch and probe, I'd have no objections to your reasoning, centsworth_II. This is a JAXA launch which most likely means that japanese tax payers paid for the largest majority of the mission, including the launch vehicle. What, then, gives NHK the right to claim the footage as theirs only? It is riding after all on the taxpayers' money, not suspended in the blackness of space all by itself.
On the other hand, capitalism corrupts. Reading the "no MARDI images from Phoenix"
thread I wonder, what if MARDI were sponsored? What effect would that have on the
decision making process? What a tangled web we weave!
Mmm...I'm not optimistic. I see where you're coming from, centsworth, but not releasing at least the raw HDTV imagery seems excessive. If NHK wants to make a slick product later on & market it, then fine; I'm sure it would knock everyone's socks off & be far superior to anything even the UMSF imagesmiths could construct, being restricted to the REALLY small screen as they are.
As is, cutting all releases off until some date to be determined defeats what I'd been assuming was the real purpose of the instrument: public outreach.
For my 2 cents worth,
We have seen more data from the Kaguya then from Mars express
In order to do certain things I think other businesses will pitch in "free" stuff if they can get some control of the results. I'm not sure if the idea is right or wrong but it will probably happen more often. But I doubt a HD camera would have been installed if it wasn't for the conditions presently being used...
only a humble opinion
Agreed this is much discussion without a lot of info on the commercial contract (if there was such). In the absence of more info, I look at what has been released so far as the "coming attractions" preview. If complete image sets were available at near HDTV quality, I imagine with the talent seen just in this forum that there would be knock-off videos available for download way before the actual studio release such that the commercial value of the studio release is reduced.
Another analogy may be to consider the scientific value of raw data that comes from missions like Cassini and the scientific value of the corrected and calibrated images release in the PDS after 6 months. Compare that with the commerical value of HD images we have seen from Kaguya and the commerical value of the full HD video "studio" release at some later date.
Music for Kaguya
http://www.sondasespaciales.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=10810&Itemid=95
http://www.sondasespaciales.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=10811&Itemid=95
Nop, do you think e-mails from non-Japanese citizens would carry any weight with NHK? (Honest question; not sure if they're trying to cultivate a foreign audience or not with the HDTV products. I haven't seen an equivalent to "BBC America" here in the US from NHK, for example, though would love to.) If true, then they might care about our opinion.
TV networks in the US do indeed respond to letter-writing campaigns, BTW.
I would swear that I had seen somewhere that NHK not only sponsored the HDTV cameras but also did the development work. IMO that makes them the PI and as such they would certainly have the right to release results when they were ready.
Not shallow at all, nop; thanks! I'll certainly send an e-mail to NHK, but hopefully a lot more Japanese citizens will do the same...they are NHK's source of revenue, and therefore their opinion really counts!
EDIT: Nop, I just checked out the NHK English pages, and can't find a "contact us" link or an e-mail address anywhere. If you can, could you please post their e-mail address?
Oh, I completely forgot to show where to contact. Very sorry, nprev, and thanks a million to foe for your kindly posting detailed and quick follow-up!
Foe & Nop, I sent what I could on that form (which is REALLY tough to get right using non-Japanese ASCII; had to insert a whole bunch of spaces!) Anyhow, here's what I wrote:
I am disappointed at the fact that KAGUYA's HDTV products are not being distributed publicly. The entire purpose of this instrument is public outreach, and NHK is doing JAXA a severe disservice by failing to publicize this accomplishment and thereby building public support for funding such missions. Furthermore, there is substantial international interest in the mission; therefore, NHK is missing an opportunity to market itself overseas, which may be an unwise business decision.
If anybody wants to copy & paste & send it again, feel free.
Here's a question for the image wizards on this forum. Using the stereo images taken by Kaguya's Terrain camera, do you think it may be possible to generate views of the Moon from a surface perspective? I mean, vertical and oblique views taken from orbit are interesting, but if we could look at lunar scenery as if we were standing on the surface, wouldn't that be mind-boggling? It would be possible to virtually visit places that will never be seen (either by rover or by humans) in our lifetime. Imagine standing on Tycho's rim and looking inside! Or whatever your favorite place is.
Maybe in a few years Google will have all the lunar 3D data available for viewing this way on Google Moon. In the meantime, what can we do with the images (if the Japanese make them available, of course)?
Surface perspective views at 20 meter/pixel will generally be awful in the forground and lousy in the midrange. Except for panoramas from mountain peaks and from crater rims (which don't have much foreground!), better shots could be made from low altitude, say 1/4 to 1 km+ simulated altitude.
OK, so it may not be a good idea to try to generate virtual surface views. You propose 1/4 to 1 km simulated altitude. How can we do it? Is there some software that can generate 3D views from two stereoscopic images?
The generation of a terrain model from stereo views is a complex and difficult process. It's one that you really have to leave to the instrument team. Bjorn is making awesome progress with Cassini stuff, however for pushbroom stereo cameras like HRSC or the lunar cameras etc - it's something the instrument team are going to be doing anyway.
The challenge is then to visualise this stuff - and that requires a 3d engine, decent hardware etc etc.
Essentially, it's a programming project of significant size.
Doug
I was somehow expecting that it would be more difficult than just plugging two images into a piece of software. I hope the imaging teams working on Kaguya, Chang'e and LRO will produce many interesting 3D views of the Moon. I am a bit tired of having just the Apollo, Surveyor and Luna sites to look at.
3-D movies have come
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/11/20071128_kaguya_e.html
And FYI here's another release.
Written only in Japanese, sorry, because it's a report presented at Space Activity Commission, a governmental committee.
They have successfully completed checkout of HDTV, TC, MI, SP, XRS, LMAG, LRS and GRS. Some new data are included.
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/11/20071128_sac_kaguya.pdf
Here's an excerpt from the updated Kaguya FAQ:
"What is the data release plan for KAGUYA?
One year after the end of the nominal operation phase (about two years after the launch), all KAGUYA products will be opened for public access online. During this one year data study period for instrument teams’ data research and validation / verification, sample data will be posted on the homepage for public outreach."
Looks like we won't have any real-time raw images to sink our teeth into this time again, just the occasional "wow" image. I suppose after waiting for 35 years (I'm not counting Clementine) another year or two is bearable. I hope the people running LRO will have a different philosophy.
A new image gallery has been opened. No new images yet but presumably it will grow.
http://wms.selene.jaxa.jp/index_e.html
Confession. I hate overly complex websites like this. Just give me a list or a set of simple thumbnails.
Phil
Hello fine folks, experts!
I have only one question which bugged me for a while. Regarding the three-dimensional terrain images by TC camera stereo view data: How do they obtain elevation data for the areas which are "hidden" completely by shadow? There is no useful pixel information which can be correlated, is there? Or do they have additional elevation data available to complement the missing data (e.g. laser ranging)? I have been reading quite some stuff about digital photogrammetry lately (which I find very interesting btw) but this remains a mystery to me. Anybody who can literally shed some light into this, please do so. Thanks a lot
Hi FordPrefect! (and thanks for all the fish! ).
Obviously is impossible to make stereography or photoclinometry for completely dark regions, however Kaguya has anoboard laser altimetry...
http://www.selene.jaxa.jp/en/equipment/lalt_e.htm
your friend Arthur Dent.
exp 42!
Thank you Arthur, err dilo for pointing that out. Laser-altimetry! I should have known better.
The image gallery mentioned above has been updated with Earthrise/Earthset images.
PS Ford - it does have a laser altimeter, but the data are not yet adequate for what you are talking about. In these earliest views the slope would just be extrapolated into shadows for visualization.
Phil
NASA just announced GRAIL http://www.nasa.gov/home/hqnews/2007/dec/HQ_07274_Grail_Mission.html and I am a little puzzled as to how this differs from the expected KAGUYA - RELAY - VRAD satellite results on MASCONs etc.
Hmm. We just might be seeing the bare beginnings of a land rush here, IMHO. Looks like there's lots of resource/geophysical survey interest all of a sudden from several quarters. The next ten years might be interesting indeed...
"I am a little puzzled as to how this differs from the expected KAGUYA - RELAY - VRAD satellite results on MASCONs etc."
I believe this is 2 spacecraft in low orbit, one following the other. Essentially a lunar version of the ultra high signal-to-noise and high resolution GRACE mission in low earth orbit. Spacecraft track each other. Kaguya/Relay simply gets the lunar orbiter radio signal out from behind the farside for otherwise "as usual" range/doppler radio tracking.
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/12/20071214_kaguya_e.html Observations using the Spectral Profiler (SP) now that's interesting.
JAXA press release: Transition to normal science operations (http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2007/12/20071221_kaguya_j.html- http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.jaxa.jp%2Fpress%2F2007%2F12%2F20071221_kaguya_j.html&langpair=ja%7Cen&hl=en&ie=UTF-8)
I think these are http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.jaxa.jp%2Fpress%2F2007%2F12%2F20071221_kaguya_j.html&langpair=ja%7Cen&hl=en&ie=UTF-8 too but I'm not sure what they show...there's an elf preventing me from sitting and watching them all the way through...there does seem to be some geometrical information in a table on the original release page, describing the locations of the videos.
--Emily
Nice. Yes, there is lat-long data for each. And the Apollo 17 flyover also shows the dark 'bay' of Le Monnier crater, containing the Lunokhod-2 site. Another video is of the Sinus Iridum area with the Lunokhod-1 site off at left early in the video.
Phil
Lens Flare. Sweet
FYI, you can download Kaguya's orbit ephemeris data during the critical phase (compressed with LZH format):
http://edu.jaxa.jp/news/file.cgi/722.lzh?id=722
The data is based on the CCSDS format (epoch, X, Y, Z, X_dot, Y_dot, Z_dot).
http://public.ccsds.org/publications/archive/502x0b1.pdf
They just posted a story, including some neat images, on successful observations using the laser altimeter and radar sounder. The results seem really important -- they report detection of near-horizontal strata as much as 500 meters below the surface of the Moon. I won't have time to study this stuff closely until after the MESSENGER flyby, which is too bad -- there's some really great science to look at here!
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2008/01/20080110_kaguya_e.html
--Emily
It will be released, and it will take some years. Meanwhile, the most complete DEM for the moon is here:
http://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2006/1367/dems/Images_16B/
- the zipped files. They are signed 16-bit TIFFs, which means they include negative values as well as positive. They can't be opened properly by Photoshop because of the negative values, but other software which can use signed TIFFs could use them. I have more information if someone needs it, but right now I'm not set up to deal with the files. If someone can convert these files to unsigned TIFFs I'd be very pleased!
Phil
I got your notes on handling that - I've been flat out HRSC Dem'ing - but I'll have a look at these over the w'end
Doug
I've just found I can open the file in OpenEV-FW. The fix is to add 9000 to every pixel value, which changes the range from (-8000 to 8000) to (1000 to 17000). There are tools in it to allow you do this, but I haven't figured out the method yet. However, I have to say, alas, that the quick look at the file in OpenEV-FW does not look very promising - still not very high quality for detailed visualizations. But there are some high resolution regional DEM datasets I'll give links to later - polar regions and Apollo groundtracks.
Phil
Some new HDTV images at:
http://wms.selene.jaxa.jp/index_e.html
The North Orientale one is especially good.
There are some good Kaguya abstracts at LPSC this yrear as well.
Phil
I made a couple of contacts with Kaguya HD related people at LPSC, and have the opportunity to ask some questions. I thought I'd see if anyone here had some suggestions for questions other than when or if the full-res video will ever be released to the Internet...
--Emily
How about pure bribery. I'd pay for a Blu-Ray disc full of it. Is that an option for the future? Is the camera excluded from the pds-style release of the rest of the instruments on board?
Did they get any film footage of the Sub Sats?
What's the pipeline for the instrument - does it record and compress a movie onboard, and then it's transmitted as a single product - or are they streamed in real time? Are they a 25fps movie, or are they slower, but presented ''sped up"?
Was the vehicle in survival mode during the recent eclipse, or did they manage to use the camera during it?
D
HDTV can be used for educational purposes (which covers a lot of things) - the NHK representative handed out contact information and terms of use. I'll give details when I'm home.
Phil
Some pretty neat movies from SELENE can be found presently on the BBC News Website. Guess they've been there for a while, and I'm just catching up These are pretty decent resolution compared with some I can see on YouTube.
http://search.bbc.co.uk/cgi-bin/search/results.pl?tab=av&q=moon%20Selene&recipe=all&scope=all&edition=i
http://www.blu-ray.com/
Pony Canyon has announced that they will release 'Kaguya Tsuki Sekai Hiko' for Blu-ray in Japan on June 18th, a full month before the DVD release. This disc will feature 17 minutes of high definition footage of the Moon and Earthrise as shot by NHK and JAXA's Kaguya probe. The footage has been set to classical music, and will give viewers a never before seen look at our closest celestial neighbor. No technical specs have been announced for the release at this time. It was originally planned for HD DVD release, but with the death of that format, those plans have been canceled.
The Apollo 11 site:
hthttp://wms.selene.jaxa.jp/data/jpn/mi/002/mi_002_1_l.jpg
The actual Apollo 11 site is a brighter patch... interesting. Apollo 15-17 pan cameras also saw this at their sites.
Phil
...I was actually just preparing to ask you to show the precise location of the site, Phil; thanks!
Descent stage exhaust? (Best guess...)
Phil, is there an html page with any caption or other information associated with the large image URL you posted? I wandered around a bit and couldn't find it.
I just have to add that I really hate that Flash image gallery that Kaguya uses.
--Emily
So far it's only here:
http://wms.selene.jaxa.jp/index_j.html
- the Japanese language version of the detestable site. Yes, I hate it too. I'm a big believer in keeping things simple. The Japanese site is updated before the English version. There's a false color version too.
Phil
West crater is not the one Armstrong ran across to, that's much closer in and not resolved in the Kaguya image.
Phil
I'm a little surprised that East Crater (var. Little West Crater) isn't resolved. Compare the Kaguya view to the following view:
http://www.hq.nasa.gov/office/pao/History/alsj/a11/a11mrf5-08.gif
Many other craters the size and depth of East Crater are resolved quite nicely in the Kaguya image.
I'm not disagreeing that this is the landing site -- the rest of the landmarks seem to match up pretty well to a cursory inspection. But I'm surprised that East isn't resolved.
-the other Doug
I always call it Little West. East crater, as far as I know, is only used on the Apollo Lunar Surface Journal. Little West Crater is used on the Defense Mapping Agency map of the Apollo 11, 12 and 14 landing sites. Either would be fine, I suppose, but you get into a habit...
Phil
I think Eagle is at the eastern end of the bright patch, comparing the Selene image with this...
http://history.nasa.gov/alsj/a11/a11mrf5-08.gif
Yes, it's odd that Little West crater is not resolved, but it's fairly shallow (unlike West) as Armstrong's surface photos of it show. You can see how other large subdued craters in that image are in danger of disappearing at higher sun angles, so perhaps that's why Little West fades away. The widest part of the bright patch appears to me to be west of the LM, so might be ascent engine scouring at lift-off, and we know the blast was strong enough to knock over the flag, set up west of the LM.
Actually, I'm pretty sure that the Apollo 11 flag was knocked over by the RCS hot-fire testing that was conducted prior to launch.
Ian.
I'm not sure about that, Ian. I seem to recall Aldrin noting that he saw the flag go over as Eagle lifted off and rose away from the landing site.
I know that the RCS hot fire tests knocked over the erectable S-band antennae on both Apollos 12 and 14, though. That may be what you're thinking of. (And at the 14 site, the flag, which never blew over, was flipped around on its pole both by the RCS hot fire and by a couple of cabin depress cycles...)
-the other Doug
The flag blew over at lift-off according to Aldrin in his book "Return to Earth". But when he describes the lunar lift-off in his other book, "Men From Earth", he doesn't mention this.
In the data acquisition 16 mm cam footage from the LM window during ascent, the flag can be seen flapping violently and the pole swaying vigorously in the exhaust blast from the LM. I have NOT single-frame stepped through the available frames (till it goes out of window-framed view), but aware of the "flag fell down" controversy, I've watched the footage everytime I see an Apollo 11 program, and it continues to look to me like the flag had not fallen over at last camera sighting.
It may have fallen over 1/4 second later, but....
I just reviewed the Apollo 11 lift-off film. The camera was started late, at an altitude of a few 100 feet I'd estimate. There is no view of the flag in any post-ignition scene. The flapping flag images are taken from the Apollo 14 lift-off movie and spliced into several documentaries about Apollo 11.
Doug,
I don't own Aldrin's book 'Return To Earth', but according to the following post on the sci.space.history newsgroup, it's in that book that Buzz attributes the flag falling to the RCS hot fire test:
http://groups.google.co.uk/group/sci.space.history/msg/e7dc973bbfc9d772
Speaking of the hot fire tests, Al Bean filmed the effects of the Apollo 12 thruster test on the lunar surface with the DAC. Although the footage is very grainy and out-of-focus, it's nonetheless quite interesting to watch.
Ian.
Speaking of the Apollo 11 ascent film...
Upon reviewing the Apollo 11 DAC footage on the wonderful Spacecraft Films boxed set, I discovered something rather interesting about the
lunar ascent sequence.
As we all know, Aldrin was late in starting the camera, so both the moment of liftoff and the subsequent ascent stage pitch-over are
sadly absent from the footage. However, in comparing the first properly exposed frame of the ascent film with a Lunar Orbiter
photograph of the landing site, I realised that the northern-most portion of Tranquility Base is visible, with the descent stage
frustratingly just out of view, hidden behind the hull of the spacecraft.
Here is the photograph of the Apollo 11 landing site taken by Lunar Orbiter V:
http://img339.imageshack.us/my.php?image=a11landingsitemy1.jpg
The green 'X' indicates the location where Eagle landed. Just to the south-west is the double-crater that was visible out of Neil's
window. To the east is the small crater that Neil visited during the EVA ('East Crater').
Now compare the Lunar Orbiter view to the first properly exposed frame of the Apollo 11 ascent DAC footage, rotated so that North is
up:
http://img341.imageshack.us/my.php?image=dacliftoffrc0.jpg
The large, shallow crater to the left, and the smaller, sharper craters that it contains, are the most obvious features that link
these two views. The green 'X' this time indicates the location of the descent stage. Some of the craters in this DAC view may be
visible in the photographs that Buzz shot out of his window prior to and after the EVA.
In conclusion, it appears that the sequence camera was activated right after pitch-over, far earlier than I had previously assumed.
Ian.
Very nice piece of work, Ian, comparing those 2 images. If anything I'd say your green cross on the lift-off frame should be even futher north and closer to the black edge of the window. That would make the lightest area of soil color, just above the green cross, correspond to the top left corner of the lighter area visible in the Kaguya photo - light because it is disturbed either by astronaut activity or LM ascent engine blast.
Regarding Aldrin's "Return to Earth", I have it here, and page 240 (Random House, Book Club Edition, 1973) says of the lift-off:
"There was no time to sightsee. I was concentrating intently on the computers, and Neil was studying the attitude indicator, but I looked up long enough to see the flag fall over. Seconds after lift-off, the LM pitched forward..."
"...There is no view of the flag in any post-ignition scene...."
etc.
That answers that.
Amazing how media conflation of events re-writes memory of what one saw live.
When we image the landing site from orbit with sub-meter resolution (color may be needed to spot the red... will that color survive this long?> or a micro rover <one or more of the proposed commercial or contest-proze missions>, we'll see where the flag ended up.
I've wondered for a while about the discrepancy between the video of the film and what Aldrin has said. This explanes the conflict neatly.
From what I have read, there would be little or nothing of the flags left by now anyway. IIRC, they were commercially-available flags made of nylon. I read somewhere that the expectation was that the color would have faded from the intense UV radiation environment in less than a year and that the flags themselves would deteriorate rapidly.
Sad, but not a big deal.
What counts are the footprints and the hardware.
Humans have been there...and we're going to go back!
I'm not sure what Buzz Aldrin hot-firing the LM RCS has to do with Kaguya, but (returning to topic) members might be interested to know that Kaguya is now on tour in cinemas across Ireland:
http://www.sbpost.ie/post/pages/p/story.aspx-qqqt=IRELAND-qqqm=news-qqqid=31872-qqqx=1.asp
Understandably, JAXA are a little annoyed to see the wonderful Prof. Honda described by the journalist as Chief Scientist for the mission, nonetheless for the Public Outreach community I think you'll agree she deserves the status of at least a minor deity.
The pictures made the evening news last night. See "Up-close look at HD space film" at:
http://www.rte.ie/news/2008/0406/6news.html
I'm afraid the contract with JAXA is strictly restricted, so the showings are for schools groups only. I have no copies to distribute outside of the Irish Film Institute programme. Sorry, but don't even ask!
Well. There seem to be a couple of different ways of looking at such things as high-definition images of the Moon.
The first one would be: "Here we have some really fantastic images. What is the best way of sharing these with a world population hungry for new vistas?"
The second one would be: "Here we have some really fantastic images. What is the best way of using them to stuff some money into our pockets?"
I hate to say it, but it seems rather obvious which of these two viewpoints JAXA has adopted... *sigh*...
-the other Doug
An interesting point, Doug. But remember, the camera was provided by Japanese broadcaster NHK, and they are the ones calling the shots, not JAXA.
I think it's more appropriate to think of this as a harbinger of things to come in the brave new world of 'New Space' or 'Moon 2.0' . When missions are flown by entrepreneurs for profit, you'll be seeing this all the time. So get used to it!
Phil
Check out these new goodies from the Kaguya site:
http://wms.selene.jaxa.jp/data/jpn/tc/003/tc_003_1_l.jpg
and
http://gisstar.gsi.go.jp/selene/
Phil
Quote from http://www.jaxa.jp/topics/2008/04_e.html :
The Earthrise movie: Sweet.
For some reason, I think I know what NHK's network ident promo's gonna look like soon...
Heck, I can even write the tagline after the dramatic music dies down: "NHK--Bringing the world to you!"
JAXA has released 720x480 DVD-quality movies of the earth-rise and the earth-set taken in November.
http://wms.selene.jaxa.jp/index_e.html
(See the topic posted on 2008/04/09 in What's New lists)
The released Kaguya image is from the Multispectral Imager, not the Terrain Camera, so it has lower resolution than the best we will get. But nobody should be surprised about the lower detail. More detail, for the same areal coverage, requires greater downlink capacity. There is always a tradeoff between resolution and coverage. Lunar Orbiter achieved very high resolution at the cost of very limited coverage - only preselected sites were imaged at high resolution for Apollo site selection. Kaguya wants to cover a wider area but can't do that at the same resolution. LRO will only give MOC-like coverage of the Moon at very high resolution, with global coverage only at 100 m resolution. And in fact for basic geologic interpretation, unlike hazard mapping for site selection, lower resolution plus broader coverage is far superior on the Moon. The universal regolith on the Moon limits the value of high resolution imaging. The situation is different on Mars, where other processes modify the surface so much.
Phil
There are 2 new movies from Kaguya HDTV http://www3.nhk.or.jp/kaguya/archive/index.html.
Few new images too.
Anybody out there knows how to catcht that ".asx" stream or somewhere else to download it from?
Nice to see they finally started to distribute higher resolution versions of the movies. Good stuff, too bad the wide angle Earthset is sped-up 4x.
As for saving the wmv media, where there's a will, there's a way...
Two VERY impressive videos!
I'm Unix inclined so I was glad to find the mmsclient freeware today.
I've captured the Kaguya stream and have placed the downloadable files here:
http://www.meridiani.co.uk/other/man_de_1m.wmv
http://www.meridiani.co.uk/other/man_de_2m.wmv
Enjoy!
Check out the Apollo 15 site!
http://www.jaxa.jp/press/2008/05/20080520_kaguya_j.html
Two small dark spots correspond exactly with the disturbed soil areas around the LM and ALSEP, as also seen in Apollo 15 Panoramic camera frame 9798.
very cool, yet still pretty blurry. patience...patience
Regarding this release, I received the following message from Shin-ichi Sobue this morning.
This new image can also be compared to a mosaic I made a while back of the landing site using stills from the Apollo 15 ascent footage:
Fantastic picture, Ian - it deserves to be a LPOD.
Phil
Maybe he refers to TV channels, like a documentary?
Awesome picture Ian! I didn't know there was even such footage available.
cool, thanks! amazing stuff. hope to see that kind of thing in my lifetime shame about the hoax people
Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)