A question here, behaviour of water on Mars |
A question here, behaviour of water on Mars |
Nov 16 2007, 01:06 AM
Post
#16
|
|
Merciless Robot Group: Admin Posts: 8784 Joined: 8-December 05 From: Los Angeles Member No.: 602 |
Mike or HDP Don, how different are the curves for sulfur salts from chlorides? (Hope that wasn't a faux pas; afraid I've forgotten most of my basic chemistry). Martian brines, if any, might be considerably different chemically then their terrestrial counterparts, and the crust is certainly sulfur-rich.
-------------------- A few will take this knowledge and use this power of a dream realized as a force for change, an impetus for further discovery to make less ancient dreams real.
|
|
|
Nov 16 2007, 01:47 AM
Post
#17
|
|
Member Group: Members Posts: 611 Joined: 23-February 07 From: Occasionally in Columbia, MD Member No.: 1764 |
And of course, the fact that water can exist, at some times, in some places - doesn't mean it does. It is a transient thing and would boil away quite easily - thus it would have to be replenished in some way. Good thread. I remember I got asked about this one by NPR when the Mars Gullies story first came out. 'Isnt Mars too cold for liquid water?' Well, yes, I answered, and Earth is too cold for liquid rock - doesnt mean it never happens..... Another data point - when I was at the Mars wind tunnel at NASA Ames doing wave generation experiments, I noticed they have a big jar of water in the chamber just inside the window to the control room (wind tunnel is open circuit - inside a large room that gets pumped down). As the pressure drops, the water starts to bump and boil, but then stops, while still liquid. (i.e. it boils until the evaporative cooling brings the temperature well below that at which the saturation vapor pressure equals ambient). We had a big tray of water on which we were hoping to generate waves - we could see on the video link that it bumped once or twice, I guess with bubbles of dissolved air coming out. Then we turned the airflow on in the hope of making waves at 10mbar or so, and saw the water glaze over - the enhancement in evaporative cooling by the airflow was enough to freeze it. Pure water has 6mb vapor pressure at 0 C (and 20mb at 20C - I remember it as 20:20) When I lived in Arizona, this issue of the metastability of water on Earth's surface was rather evident - spill water in the kitchen, no problem, it'll dry up by itself in 3 minutes. At the DPS conference in Monterey (2003?) I raised the question in connection with Titan (known to have 50% or so relative humidity, so where are the oceans?) - I pointed out that Earth is 60% covered in water, and yet we can hang out laundry to dry. Clearly this wouldnt work unless the relative humidity were much lower than 100% (because of circulation to higher altitudes, which dries the air..) Anyway, it remains a subtle issue. I'd urge people read Mike Hecht's work on the topic (he has a rather fresh perspective). And I think Titan (where ethane takes the role of salt, in lowering the saturation vapor pressure of the volatile component in a solution) will be very instructive in comparisons with Mars. So - Doug's words 'transient' and 'replenished' are key - if the system is out of equilibrium, then lots of things are possible. And I guess I am learning over the years that disequlibrium isnt that hard to generate... |
|
|
Nov 16 2007, 01:03 PM
Post
#18
|
|
Senior Member Group: Members Posts: 3516 Joined: 4-November 05 From: North Wales Member No.: 542 |
|
|
|
Nov 16 2007, 08:27 PM
Post
#19
|
|
Member Group: Members Posts: 384 Joined: 4-January 07 Member No.: 1555 |
Mike or HDP Don, how different are the curves for sulfur salts from chlorides? (Hope that wasn't a faux pas; afraid I've forgotten most of my basic chemistry). Martian brines, if any, might be considerably different chemically then their terrestrial counterparts, and the crust is certainly sulfur-rich. Very different, in that common sulfates (e.g., of Mg) can't depress freezing the point more than about 5 degrees C, whereas NaCl (sodium chloride table salt) depresses it about 20 C, MgCl2 about 34 C, and CaCl2 about 50 C. Chloride salt mixtures gain several extra degrees below that (so-called eutectic freezing). Therefore any low temperature brines on or in Mars would have to be dominated by chlorides, a group of salts that can't normally be detected by infrared spectroscopy (TES and THEMIS from orbit, and Mini-TES on the rovers). That is, Mars could be chloride rich, and the salts would be difficult to detect. In this regard, their greater solubility and greater tendency to be frost leached (via freezing point depression) suggests that chloride salts should be less persistent than sulfate salts at the martian surface. Nevertheless, chloride-rich areas on Mars have recently been inferred by this very lack of an IR signal - they look something like a "black hole" to IR spectrometers. See, e.g., Fall AGU abstract P13D-1563 by M.M. Osterloo et al. http://www.agu.org/cgi-bin/SFgate/SFgate?&...P13D-1563" Several of these inferred chloride-rich areas were suggested as possible landing sites for the Mars Science Lander (MSL), but didn't make the semi-final cut a couple of weeks ago. Gsnorgathon, with regard to cooking with salt, I stand corrected. I perhaps should have said, "among other reasons" or "one reason" and not "the reason". (Adding salt is commonly recommended even for the simplest of recipies such as boiling an egg, where the taste of the salt might be undetectable.) Ngunn, with regard to Mike Hecht, you could start here: http://www.lpi.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2001/pdf/1364.pdf although he also published longer papers later. Personally, I enjoyed the exciting description of metastable water in an active outflow channel in the novel "Red Mars". -- HDP Don |
|
|
Nov 16 2007, 08:51 PM
Post
#20
|
|
Senior Member Group: Members Posts: 3516 Joined: 4-November 05 From: North Wales Member No.: 542 |
Thanks for that Hecht link. Definitely some counter-intuitive things going on, and a subject well worth getting one's head round properly.
|
|
|
Nov 16 2007, 08:57 PM
Post
#21
|
|
Senior Member Group: Moderator Posts: 2785 Joined: 10-November 06 From: Pasadena, CA Member No.: 1345 |
.... I strongly suspect that most recipes call for salt to be added before boiling so that whatever's being boiled will absorb the salt, and thus enhance its flavor. Actually, the advice is more a safety issue. If you add salt (or any other powder) to water that is boiling or very near boiling, the addition of so many new nucleation sites (rough edges and pits from salt xtals) could cause sudden boilover. [There was a Mythbusters episode where they confirmed that adding sugar to water that was zapped to superheating could cause the water to violently boilover. (Season 1, Episode 4)] Mythbusters index: http://mythbustersresults.com/ [Very cool video of adding coffee powder to superheated water (WARNING: DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME OR IN MY LAB): http://www.phys.unsw.edu.au/~jw/superheating.html] -Mike -------------------- Some higher resolution images available at my photostream: http://www.flickr.com/photos/31678681@N07/
|
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 01:17 AM
Post
#22
|
|
Merciless Robot Group: Admin Posts: 8784 Joined: 8-December 05 From: Los Angeles Member No.: 602 |
Very different, in that common sulfates (e.g., of Mg) can't depress freezing the point more than about 5 degrees C, whereas NaCl (sodium chloride table salt) depresses it about 20 C, MgCl2 about 34 C, and CaCl2 about 50 C. Chloride salt mixtures gain several extra degrees below that (so-called eutectic freezing). Thanks! That's really a dramatic difference. I presume those values are referenced to terrestrial standard temperature & pressure? Has anyone crunched the numbers for average Martian STP (if they've derived that in any meaningful form yet, that is)? -------------------- A few will take this knowledge and use this power of a dream realized as a force for change, an impetus for further discovery to make less ancient dreams real.
|
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 01:40 AM
Post
#23
|
|
Member Group: Members Posts: 384 Joined: 4-January 07 Member No.: 1555 |
Thanks! That's really a dramatic difference. I presume those values are referenced to terrestrial standard temperature & pressure? Has anyone crunched the numbers for average Martian STP (if they've derived that in any meaningful form yet, that is)? Inasmuch as brine, salt, and ice are all condensed (non-gaseous) phases, changes to pressure should have very little effect until the pressure gets so low that the brine boils or the ice sublimates (definitely a consideration for Mars - but less of a concern for chloride brines, owing to the tremendous lowering of the activity of H2O in such brines, as mentioned above). The salts might lose waters of hydration too, although this doesn't affect the basic argument about freezing point depression. A lot of basic data is given in a 1980 Icarus paper by Brass, "Stability of brines on Mars" that Knauth and I cited in our 2002 and 2003 papers. And Juramike - thanks for the added insight on the safety of adding salt to water before boiling it - yet another reason to do so, and undoubtedly the most important one. I guess you can tell this professor doesn't cook much. -- HDP Don |
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 01:50 AM
Post
#24
|
|
Merciless Robot Group: Admin Posts: 8784 Joined: 8-December 05 From: Los Angeles Member No.: 602 |
They don't call ya Herr Doktor Professor for nothin'! Thanks, Don; most interesting and informative, as always.
-------------------- A few will take this knowledge and use this power of a dream realized as a force for change, an impetus for further discovery to make less ancient dreams real.
|
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 03:03 AM
Post
#25
|
|
Member Group: Members Posts: 384 Joined: 4-January 07 Member No.: 1555 |
They don't call ya Herr Doktor Professor for nothin'! Actually, no one calls me that but me, AFAIK (a form of self-mockery). Actual Herr Doktor Professors I've met over the years can NEVER make a mistake, practically by definition. That pretty much rules me out as the real thing, I'm happy to say. -- HDP Don |
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 03:49 PM
Post
#26
|
|
Merciless Robot Group: Admin Posts: 8784 Joined: 8-December 05 From: Los Angeles Member No.: 602 |
[Very cool video of adding coffee powder to superheated water (WARNING: DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME OR IN MY LAB): http://www.phys.unsw.edu.au/~jw/superheating.html] -Mike ...son of a <clink!!!> Rest assured, I'll never try this at home or anywhere else, period, and thanks for the public service announcement! What I'm getting here is that soluables usually depress the freezing point but accelerate the boiling point. Is that a fair generalization? -------------------- A few will take this knowledge and use this power of a dream realized as a force for change, an impetus for further discovery to make less ancient dreams real.
|
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 05:02 PM
Post
#27
|
|
Senior Member Group: Moderator Posts: 2785 Joined: 10-November 06 From: Pasadena, CA Member No.: 1345 |
...son of a <clink!!!> Rest assured, I'll never try this at home or anywhere else, period, and thanks for the public service announcement! What I'm getting here is that soluables usually depress the freezing point but accelerate the boiling point. Is that a fair generalization? The effect on the water boil-over was due to nucleation. If you added sand (insoluble) it would have done the exact same thing and boiled over. Perfectly smooth surfaces prevent boiling and crystallization. (No good nucleation sites or crystal defects to start the phase change). So you can get superheating and supercooling. Add a rough surface (or scratch the glass vessel) and bingo! you get nucleation or crystallization. (Scratching the inside of a flask is a great way to start crystals growing). So if you go against my advice and try this at home, a brand new coffee cup with no interior dings will work best. Same deal could happen on Mars or Earth. You have a fluid which goes through a smooth "pipe" without any nucleation sites, and you could get fluid at temperatures/pressures outside where it would normally be in the phase diagram. Throw in a defect and you get a geyser, or it freezes up, depending on just where it is in the phase diagram. This is applicable to either pure materials or brines. (Although the vapor phase from a geyser would be pretty much pure water, and the first phase to freeze out of a brine would likely be water if it is not at it's eutectic.) -Mike -------------------- Some higher resolution images available at my photostream: http://www.flickr.com/photos/31678681@N07/
|
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 05:25 PM
Post
#28
|
|
Member Group: Members Posts: 401 Joined: 5-January 07 From: Manchester England Member No.: 1563 |
Thank you very much one and all, I can look foward to a very interesting conversation ensuing on monday when we see each other again!
-------------------- |
|
|
Nov 17 2007, 05:38 PM
Post
#29
|
|
Senior Member Group: Admin Posts: 4763 Joined: 15-March 05 From: Glendale, AZ Member No.: 197 |
The effect on the water boil-over was due to nucleation. If you added sand (insoluble) it would have done the exact same thing and boiled over. A similar process happens with super-cooled liquids. When I was in college I lived in a very dry, high-altitude town (that nprev is familiar with). I used to keep a bottle of club soda (carbonated water) in my small dorm refrigerator (as I was a Scotch drinker even back then). Every now and then the cheap refrigerator would go out of whack and I'd find everything inside frozen solid, except for the sealed bottle of soda water (occasionally it would be Diet Coke). So I would call over some of my neighbors to demonstrate what happens when a crystal of just about anything was dropped into this supercooled liquid. It's probably best to do this with a plastic bottle, as I'm not sure what might happen with a glass container when the entire contents go "thud" and turn to ice in a millisecond. (For those of you still in college this works best on Freshmen engineering majors, but not the ladies. ) -------------------- If Occam had heard my theory, things would be very different now.
|
|
|
Nov 18 2007, 12:15 AM
Post
#30
|
|
Merciless Robot Group: Admin Posts: 8784 Joined: 8-December 05 From: Los Angeles Member No.: 602 |
Rats...knew I shoulda gone to EGD's alma mater. In addition to learning about freezing stuff instantaneously, it's only 90 miles from home, so Mom could've still done my laundry...
-------------------- A few will take this knowledge and use this power of a dream realized as a force for change, an impetus for further discovery to make less ancient dreams real.
|
|
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 8th June 2024 - 06:02 AM |
RULES AND GUIDELINES Please read the Forum Rules and Guidelines before posting. IMAGE COPYRIGHT |
OPINIONS AND MODERATION Opinions expressed on UnmannedSpaceflight.com are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of UnmannedSpaceflight.com or The Planetary Society. The all-volunteer UnmannedSpaceflight.com moderation team is wholly independent of The Planetary Society. The Planetary Society has no influence over decisions made by the UnmannedSpaceflight.com moderators. |
SUPPORT THE FORUM Unmannedspaceflight.com is funded by the Planetary Society. Please consider supporting our work and many other projects by donating to the Society or becoming a member. |