[X] My Assistant

[MahFL]

Meteorite

[djellison]

Glances off his hand...then makes a 1ft wide crater.

Yeah.

Right.

[helvick]

There's so much wrong with this reporting that I don't know where to start. The thing that hit the ground might well be a meteorite - someone who is [a] trustworthy] and [b] has some technical ability to identify meteorites and [c] actually has it to test would be able to tell for certain but for the sake of argument let's just assume that it is. The problems with the rest of the story are numerous though. For starters if it was red hot, visible as a ball of light heading to our victim and then went on to make a "foot wide crater" in the ground it would have left very little of his hand behind if he had been hit by it. Secondly it's extremely unlikely that it would hit the ground still glowing or that a "ball of light" would be visible heading towards you. Thirdly for something to make a foot wide hole in the ground it has to pack a lot of energy - a pea sized meteorite reaching the ground is not going to do that unless the road in question was a bowl of very fine dust and even then it's a major stretch.

If he was hit\near the impact of something that was glowing so much that there was a visible "ball of light", made a foot wide hole in the ground and he saw it coming in at anything other than straight down from above then I would call the cops and start look for someone who had fired it at him.

[stevesliva]

The Telegraph definitely has more embellishment than the space.com article. Neither article really adds up to plausible. The kid's firsthand comments on what happened are also implausible.

http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastro...by-a-meteorite/

[MahFL]

The telegraph article does say he has a nasty 3 inch gash on his hand, which is pretty big for a 14 year olds hand.

Edit, scar looks like 1.5 inches not 3.

[MahFL]

Scar and pea sized meteorite.......